Go to ...
- Does your car pass to the trustee when sequestration is awarded?
- Where does the £3,000 car figure actually come from?
- What is the vehicle figure for vesting in a sequestration?
- How is a car valued for any of this?
- What if you need the car for work?
- What happens to a car you are still paying finance on?
- How does a car affect your debtor contribution order?
- Related guides
- Frequently asked questions
Your whole estate vests in the trustee on the date of sequestration under section 78(1) of the Bankruptcy (Scotland) Act 2016, and a car you own is part of it unless something takes it out.
Two different figures are printed for what you may keep, and they come from two different tests. Almost every page in this market gives one of them and calls it the rule.
Need your car for work and facing sequestration? Get free advice on where you stand.
No obligation
★★★★★Rated 5 stars on Google
For a lot of people the car is the first question, well before the credit cards. It gets them to work, to the school run and to a hospital appointment.
What follows separates the figures, sets out what is published about valuation, and deals with a car on finance. How sequestration works covers the process itself.
Does your car pass to the trustee when sequestration is awarded?
As a starting point, yes. Section 78(1) vests the whole estate of the debtor in the trustee, as at the date of sequestration.
What vesting means in practice
Vesting transfers the right rather than the keys. The trustee’s job under section 50 is to recover, manage and realise the estate for the creditors, and what a trustee in sequestration does sets out the functions in full.
A car with little or no realisable value is rarely worth a trustee’s time. The question is always what it would raise against the cost and disruption of taking it.
Vesting is subject to section 88
Section 78(1) is expressly subject to section 88, which is where the exclusions from vesting live. That is the provision a vehicle argument runs through.
Where does the £3,000 car figure actually come from?
From section 2(3)(b) of the 2016 Act, which opens with the words for the purposes of subsection (2)(c) and (d). Those are the Minimal Asset Process asset tests.
What the disregard does
A vehicle you reasonably require and which is worth no more than £3,000 is left out of the asset calculation altogether, under section 2(3)(b).
So it decides whether you get into a Minimal Asset Process, not whether a trustee in a full administration may sell your car. Whether you keep your car in a MAP deals with that route.
The Accountant in Bankruptcy prints the same figure more widely
Its guidance on assets says at paragraph 4.12 that legislation only provides for debtors to retain ownership of a vehicle of up to £3,000 in value and where it is reasonably required.
Its debtor guide puts the same figure to the public as a vehicle you may be able to keep.
What is the vehicle figure for vesting in a sequestration?
£1,000, on the statutory route. That is a lower number than the guidance prints, and the difference is worth understanding before you apply.
The route the statute takes
Section 88(1)(a) keeps out of the estate property kept outside a dwellinghouse that could not competently be attached, which leads to section 11(1)(b) of the Debt Arrangement and Attachment (Scotland) Act 2002: a vehicle reasonably required by the debtor and not exceeding £1,000 in value.
A car on a driveway or in the street is kept outside a dwellinghouse. Section 88(1)(b) is the limb that deals with property kept inside one, and it works by a different test.
That is the same route a protected trust deed uses, because a trust deed conveys the estate except what would be excluded on sequestration. The two solutions share the figure.
The two published figures do not sit together
| The source | What it says about a car | What kind of statement it is |
|---|---|---|
| The Accountant in Bankruptcy's debtor guide | You may be able to keep a vehicle reasonably required by you with a value of no more than £3,000 | Guidance, published for debtors |
| The Accountant in Bankruptcy's notes on assets, paragraph 4.12 | Legislation only provides for debtors to retain ownership of a vehicle of up to £3,000 in value and where it is reasonably required | Guidance for advisers using the common financial tool |
| Section 2(3)(b) of the 2016 Act | The £3,000 disregard, expressly for the purposes of section 2(2)(c) and (d) | Statute, and those are the Minimal Asset Process asset tests |
| Section 88(1)(a), with section 11(1)(b) of the 2002 Act | Property kept outside a dwellinghouse that could not be attached: a vehicle reasonably required by the debtor and not exceeding £1,000 in value | Statute, and this is the vesting route |
| National Debtline | A car worth more than £3,000 may be sold even if you need it for work | Charity guidance, and it is the plainest warning published |
We are not going to reconcile them for you, because nothing published does. Ask your trustee for the position on your own vehicle in writing.
Four figures, four different tests
| The figure | What it applies to | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| £3,000 | A vehicle you reasonably require, left out of the Minimal Asset Process asset count | Section 2(3)(b), which applies for the purposes of section 2(2)(c) and (d) |
| £1,000 | Any single asset in the Minimal Asset Process tests | Section 2(2)(d) |
| £1,000 | A vehicle reasonably required by you and kept outside a dwellinghouse, outside what would vest on sequestration | Section 88(1)(a), routed to section 11(1)(b) of the Debt Arrangement and Attachment (Scotland) Act 2002 |
| £3,000 | The minimum debt for full administration on a debtor application | Section 2(8)(a), an unrelated test that happens to use the same number |
Full administration sequestration has a minimum debt of £3,000 under section 2(8)(a). That figure is unrelated to the vehicle disregard, which happens to use the same number.
The provisions of the 2016 Act in that table have been in force since 30 November 2016 and none of their figures has been amended since. The £1,000 vehicle figure sits in the 2002 Act instead, and section 88(1)(a) is what reaches it.
Money already coming out of your wages? Get free help in under 60 seconds
How is a car valued for any of this?
By an independent source, in practice. There is no statutory valuation method, and that is a genuine gap rather than an oversight in the guidance.
The power exists and has never been used
Nothing sets out how an asset is to be valued for these limits. Section 2(4) allows valuation regulations to be made and none ever has been, so ask your money adviser how yours will be treated.
Market value, resale value and forced sale value are all absent from the Act and the regulations. How assets are valued against the MAP limits goes through what is and is not published.
What the Accountant in Bankruptcy asks for
Paragraph 4.9 of its notes on assets wants a valuation from an independent recognised source, naming Glass’s guide, Parkers or a car dealership, with an explanation where the figure looks low for the make, model and year.
Its evidence checklist says that where a vehicle is valued over £3,000 the Minimal Asset Process criteria will not be met.
Value is not the same as equity
A car worth £4,500 with finance outstanding on it is not a £4,500 asset in your hands. It is also not automatically yours to keep, because the finance agreement decides who owns what.
The gap between those two ideas is where most disputes start. Establish the value and the settlement figure separately, and put both in front of your adviser.
Get the valuation before the application, not after
A valuation obtained at the last minute is the commonest cause of delay in this part of the process. It is also the document that decides whether a Minimal Asset Process is open to you.
Where the figure looks low for the make, model and year, expect to be asked why. A short note about mileage, condition or a known fault usually settles it.
What if you need the car for work?
Needing it goes to whether it is reasonably required, which is half of the test. It does not raise the value figure.
How the argument is actually made
The notes on assets tell advisers to confirm why the vehicle is necessary, giving a work commute, mobility needs and a rural location as examples.
So put the reason in writing at the assessment stage with something to back it up. A bus timetable that does not reach your shift start is evidence.
The warning nobody else prints as plainly
National Debtline says a car worth more than £3,000 may be sold even if you need it for work, and that a cheaper replacement is normally allowed to be bought from the proceeds.
A replacement is a matter for the trustee rather than an entitlement you can insist on. Get the position confirmed before you commit to anything.
A second car is a harder case
Reasonably required is doing real work in that phrase. A vehicle nobody in the household needs is a different argument from the only car a working family has.
Tools of the trade are separate again
The Accountant in Bankruptcy says you can keep tools you need for your trade up to a value of £1,000, and National Debtline gives the same figure for tools and books. Neither attaches a section number to it.
What happens to a car you are still paying finance on?
It depends on the agreement, because what vests is your right or interest and that is not the same as owning the car.
Why the agreement decides it
On hire purchase or conditional sale the vehicle is not yours until the agreement says so. Section 145(5) separately preserves a secured creditor’s right to enforce a security, so a personal obligation can be discharged while rights over goods carry on.
Where you bought the car outright with an unsecured loan, the loan is an ordinary debt covered by the discharge and the car is an asset in the estate. Which debts are not written off covers that split.
What to check before you apply
| The question | Why it matters | What to do about it |
|---|---|---|
| What kind of agreement is it? | Hire purchase, conditional sale, a personal contract purchase, or an ordinary loan used to buy the car outright | Only the last of those makes you the owner from the start |
| What does it say happens on insolvency? | Many agreements let the lender terminate | Read the clause rather than assuming |
| Is the car worth more than the settlement figure? | That difference is what a trustee would be looking at | A car in negative equity is rarely worth realising |
| Is it a Motability or similar scheme vehicle? | A scheme vehicle usually belongs to the scheme rather than to you | The Accountant in Bankruptcy asks for the agreement as evidence |
| Can the monthly payment be allowed as expenditure? | It is put forward in the contribution assessment | Take the agreement to your money adviser before you apply |
The evidence checklist asks for the agreement itself where a vehicle is on a scheme or on finance, so have it to hand at the first appointment.
How does a car affect your debtor contribution order?
A debtor contribution order is set using the common financial tool, so it is calculated from what your budget shows you can afford rather than from what you owe.
Running costs are expenditure
Regulation 15(2) of the 2016 Regulations takes your whole surplus income above the lower of the published trigger figures and your actual expenditure. Every pound allowed for the car comes off the surplus.
| The cost | How it is treated | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel and travel to work | Put forward as expenditure in the assessment | The notes tell advisers to confirm why the vehicle is necessary, such as a work commute or a rural location |
| Insurance, road tax and maintenance | Assessed against the published trigger figures | The lower of the trigger figure and what you actually spend is used |
| Expenditure above a trigger figure | The Accountant in Bankruptcy, the trustee varying an order under section 95, the court or a trust deed trustee may allow it where satisfied it is reasonable | Regulation 15(3)(a) of the Bankruptcy (Scotland) Regulations 2016 |
| Evidence for it | Evidence of why the expenditure is reasonable has to be provided | Regulation 15(4) |
| A contingency allowance | You must be allowed to decide to retain one, capped at up to 10 per cent of the assessed contribution | Regulation 15(3)(b), with the cap in regulation 16(1) |
| Income solely from benefits and tax credits | No contribution is due at all | Regulation 15(7) |
There is no percentage in the calculation
The assessment produces the whole of the assessed surplus rather than a share of it, which is why the expenditure figures are worth arguing properly. How a debtor contribution order is calculated sets out the method step by step.
The order outlasts your discharge
It normally runs for 48 months, which is longer than the twelve months to discharge. The payments carry on after you are discharged.
Budget for the payment period rather than for the twelve months. How to apply for sequestration covers what happens in what order.
Frequently asked questions
Will the trustee take my car straight away?
Your estate vests in the trustee at the date of sequestration under section 78(1), but vesting is subject to section 88 and a trustee has to decide whether realising the vehicle is worth doing. Ask for the position on your own car in writing.
Is the car limit £3,000 or £1,000?
Both figures are real and they belong to different tests. The £3,000 in section 2(3)(b) is the Minimal Asset Process disregard, while the vesting route runs through section 88(1)(a) to section 11(1)(b) of the 2002 Act, where the figure is £1,000.
Is the limit based on value or on what I paid?
It is the value of the vehicle rather than its cost. The Accountant in Bankruptcy wants a valuation from an independent recognised source such as Glass’s guide, Parkers or a car dealership.
Can I keep a car I need to get to work?
Needing it supports the argument that it is reasonably required, which is only half of the test. National Debtline says a car worth more than £3,000 may still be sold even where it is needed for work.
What happens to a car on hire purchase in sequestration?
What vests is your right or interest rather than the vehicle itself, so the agreement decides a great deal of it. Take the agreement to a money adviser before you apply.
Do car running costs count in my monthly contribution?
Yes, they are assessed as expenditure using the published trigger figures. Regulation 15(3)(a) lets the Accountant in Bankruptcy allow expenditure above a trigger figure where satisfied it is reasonable, and regulation 15(4) requires the evidence for it, so put the evidence forward.
How is a Motability car treated?
A scheme vehicle is usually the scheme’s rather than yours, and the Accountant in Bankruptcy’s evidence checklist asks for the agreement. Raise it with your money adviser before the application goes in.
Can I keep my work tools as well as the car?
The Accountant in Bankruptcy says you can keep tools you need for your trade up to a value of £1,000, and National Debtline gives the same figure for tools and books. Neither attaches a section number to that figure.
Get free, confidential help with your debts today
Free, confidential advice on where you stand and what can be stopped.
Written as general information about Scottish debt law rather than regulated financial or legal advice, and your own circumstances may change the answer. Free, impartial help is available from Citizens Advice Scotland, StepChange, National Debtline and Advice Direct Scotland.